Problems We Solve

About Us

Case Studies

Talk to Us

You’re probably not spending too little on marketing. You’re likely spending it on the wrong things, for the wrong time horizon.

Results are still coming in, just without the momentum the business needs. Growth feels harder and less predictable than it should and each quarter seems to demand more effort for the same return. So you’ve changed the channel mix. You may have switched agencies. Sometimes that buys a few months of improvement. More often it buys a new version of the same problem, because the fault usually sits in the structure underneath your tactics and swapping tactics isn’t the solution.

Here’s what we see. Most marketing plans are built by looking backwards. What worked last year gets more budget this year. The campaign that performed gets a re-run. The event that generated leads gets more investment. The issue with this is that the market doesn’t stand still, particularly with AI entering the mix.

Buyers are researching differently, increasingly through AI tools that summarise your category before someone ever reaches your website. Channels are shifting and media performance is getting harder to read, with platforms reporting more on their own terms and less on the buying journey that’s important to you. What worked in the past is becoming a weak predictor of what works next.

This is hard to see from the inside. Your team is busy. Budget is being spent. The reports show green shoots. Yet none of it is building real conviction. So before you decide what to fix next, you need to ask whether you’re working on the right problem. at all.

 

The five traps that make marketing less effective over time

Across our years sitting in the CMO seat, and the businesses we’ve worked with since, the symptoms vary. The underlying causes rarely do.

1. The single-channel trap

A channel works, so you lean in. Paid search (PPC) is the classic. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Costs start climbing, an algorithm changes, AI Overviews start to take the clicks you used to get. Performance drops and there’s a gap where growth used to come from, with an urge to throw more money at the problem. Spending harder on that channel deepens the dependency, because the underlying problem is a commercial engine built around a single point of failure. It can carry a business for a while, but not to scale.

Different channels do different jobs. Search captures people who are already looking. Content and PR shape what buyers believe before they start. Events and partnerships build the trust that closes deals. Keeping sales flowing means doing several jobs at once.

It’s also worth thinking about where you’re getting your advice from. If your agency runs one channel, or is paid on the media it manages, more budget in that channel is the natural recommendation. It’s the result of them not having an independent and holistic view across the end to end buyer journey. 

2. The direction trap

There’s no shortage of activity. You’ve got dedicated role and/or agencies delivering paid and organic search, PR, social and email. Diversifying is the right instinct. Channels are fragmenting, and each one needs a more dedicated approach than it did five years ago. The problem is diversifying without direction.

When each channel runs in isolation, nobody owns the journey. A buyer sees one message on LinkedIn, a different one in an ad and a third on your website. Your activity isn’t additive, it’s potentially conflicting and confusing.

Joined-up marketing needs three things agreed before the activity starts: who you’re talking to, what you want them to believe, and what job each channel does in getting them to buy. Someone has to oversee the end-to-end path to purchase, not just their slice of it. Without that, you’re investing without direction, diluting the return.

3. The strategic shift trap

The business has moved. New product, new market, new investor, a rebrand, a different buyer. The business your marketing was built for no longer exists.

Marketing and sales should deliver against where the business is heading, not where it’s been. When strategy shifts, marketing has to stop and rethink what it’s there to deliver: different audiences, a different proposition, different channels, different measures of success.

Many don’t. The same plan rolls forward with new messaging bolted on, and the results start to show up in a performance gap.

4. The sameness trap

This is the one we see most in businesses that have done well and then reach a plateau. We call it the graveyard of the middle. As a business grows, the temptation is to broaden. More segments, more use cases, a message that covers all. The result is a business that sounds like every other competitor: same claims, same imagery, same “trusted partner” language. When buyers can’t tell you apart, they default to price, or to a brand they already know and trust.

It’s better to be sharp and specific to a defined audience than vaguely appealing to everyone. Know why you win. Talk to your best customers, find the real reason they chose you, then say it often and consistently.

This matters more now that AI tools are answering buyers’ questions. An AI summary of your category rewards the brand with a fresh perspective, offering up a clear, consistent point of view. Everyone else gets flattened into a blanket overview.

5. Short-term myopia

This underpins the other four, and it’s the hardest to spot because it doesn’t feel like failure while it’s happening. Pipeline is coming in. Attribution looks healthy. Looking at the metrics that get reported, marketing is working.

But cut the budget, switch the agency or pause the campaigns, and the pipeline dries up within weeks. That isn’t a growth engine. It’s a tap that can dry up in an instant.

The businesses that grow consistently don’t just capture demand. They build it, in parallel, all the time. That’s the difference between a pipeline that needs constant refilling and one that starts to feed itself.

 

Why short-termism is the most expensive habit in marketing

Every marketer understands the pull. Spend today, see results this quarter, attribute them neatly in the board pack. The problem is that performance marketing only harvests the small share of your market that’s ready to buy right now. Most of your future customers aren’t in market today. If they don’t know you by the time they are, you’re paying full price to compete for them against everyone else.

And harvest channels erode. Audiences tune out familiar formats, competitors pile into the same auctions, and costs rise. That was true before AI. Now AI is rewiring search itself, serving answers before a click ever happens. Standing still on your channel mix means going backwards. The businesses that keep growing are a step ahead of that erosion, not reacting once the numbers drop. 

The long and the short of it

Les Binet and Peter Field’s analysis of decades of IPA effectiveness data shows that long-term brand building is the most effective driver of sustained growth in market share, revenue and profit. Their widely quoted benchmark is around 60:40 brand to activation for consumer brands, with B2B closer to an even split.

If most of your budget sits in sales activation, you’re not alone. It’s one of the most consistent patterns we see in scaling businesses. When you’re smaller, harvesting existing demand gets you a long way. The mistake is carrying that mindset forward while the business scales in every other way: people, product, process, everything except getting your brand known.

Recognising when to dial up brand takes a senior marketer who can make the case, and a CEO willing to back a longer-term view.

An ecommerce business we recently worked with was putting 80% of its budget into sales activation. After seven years of growth, sales had stalled. The CEO believed the same approach would take them to £10m, then £15m. Our research told a different story. Brand awareness was low. Without investment in broadening brand appeal, the marketing engine had been running on demand it wasn’t replacing, with growth plateauing. Getting the brand seen by a wider audience is now helping to recharge sales growth.

Why this matters more now

Customer acquisition costs have risen by around 60% over the past five years. When the cost of buying a customer keeps climbing, inefficient spend stops being wasteful and starts being unsustainable.

At the same time, AI has raised the floor of execution for everyone. Decent copy, reasonable targeting, functional campaigns: any competitor can now match them with the right prompt. Good execution is not a differentiator.

What AI can’t replicate is a brand that a specific buyer already knows, trusts and thinks of first. And brand strength now shapes AI visibility directly. Ahrefs’ 2025 study of 75,000 brands found that how often a brand is mentioned across the web was more strongly linked to appearing in Google’s AI Overviews than backlinks. Put simply, the brands AI cites are the brands people already talk about. Under invest in brand and you become invisible in the channel your buyers are increasingly moving to.

 

How to diagnose which problem you actually have

Ask yourself these simple questions: 

  1. If your best-performing channel halved next quarter, what would replace it? If the honest answer is “nothing”, your commercial engine has a single point of failure and your growth is unlikely to be sustainable.
  2. Can you name the job each channel does, and who owns the end-to-end journey? If each agency or team member can only describe their own slice of delivery, you have activity rather than a growth engine. Buyers are likely getting mixed messages, with your marketing creating confusion rather than clarity.
  3. Put your business strategy next to your marketing plan. Do they describe the same business? If the plan was written for the products, markets or buyers you had two years ago, your marketing execution is pulling in the wrong direction.
  4. Could a competitor put their logo on your website without anyone noticing? Ask your best customers why they chose you. If their answers are vague, inconsistent or something any competitor could claim, your positioning isn’t distinctive enough.
  5. Could you turn off paid media for 90 days and keep a healthy pipeline? If not, your activation budget is capturing demand, not creating it. In practice you’re harvesting a crop without planting a new one.

Most businesses we work with find two or three of these apply. The fifth is almost always one of them, because it’s the trap that makes the other four harder to escape.

 

What to do next

If these questions have surfaced issues you can’t resolve internally, that’s exactly what our marketing audit is for. Open Velocity partners have experience in a CMO or Marketing Director position, so we’ve sat where you’re sitting. Within a few weeks, we’ll give you a clear view of what’s broken, what matters most and what to fix first. 

 

Further reading

 

Questions we’re often asked

What is a marketing audit, and what does it involve?

A marketing audit is a structural review of how your marketing works, not just how individual campaigns perform. It looks at your target audience, positioning, channel mix, customer journey, team and agency set-up, and the balance between brand and activation. The output should be a clear diagnosis and a prioritised action plan, not a long list of observations.

How do I justify moving budget from short-term ROI to brand investment?

Don’t frame it as either/or. Ring-fence a share of budget for demand creation and move in stages rather than all at once. Agree lead indicators up front, such as branded search volume, direct traffic, share of search, mentions in AI answers, win rates and sales cycle length, so you demonstrate progress before revenue follows. Then frame the case as risk reduction: the business currently depends on channels whose costs only go one way. The line that tends to land is “we’ve outgrown our current marketing operating model”, not “we need more budget for brand”.

What is a marketing strategy, and why does it matter?

A marketing strategy is the set of choices that sits above your activity: who you’re for, what you want them to believe about you, how you’ll reach them and how you’ll measure success. A plan of campaigns is not a strategy. Strategy is what gives every tactic a reason to exist, and what lets you say no to the ones that don’t fit. Without it, each channel optimises for itself and nothing compounds.

Should I change my agency?

Maybe, but diagnose first. If the brief is wrong, a new agency will simply execute the wrong brief more enthusiastically. Many of the agency relationships we see breaking down are a symptom of missing direction, not poor delivery. Fix the strategy and you’ll know exactly what you need an agency to do, and whether your current one can do it.

How does brand affect whether AI tools recommend my business?

AI tools build their answers from what’s said about you across the web: reviews, press, articles, forums and your own content. Brands that are mentioned often, and described consistently, are more likely to be cited. That makes AI visibility a brand and positioning question first, and a technical one second. If your message is generic, AI will describe you generically, alongside everyone else.

Tags

Share

Facebook
LinkedIn

AUTHOR

Lisa Wood

Lisa has built brands, grown businesses and optimised marketing performance across Private Equity, start-up and corporate businesses. She’s a passionate customer advocate, shaped by 30 years of marketing experience and executive leadership roles at customer-centric brands including first direct and Atom Bank.
Open Velocity
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.